What was Bethlehem’s star?

What was Bethlehem’s star?

The Three Wise Kings, Catalan Atlas, 1375, fol. V (Public Domain)

Originally published 26 December 1983

Our stars come from Ire­land,” says Wal­lace Stevens in the title of a poem. And if you watch the stars from night to night you will indeed see how they come up out of the Atlantic hori­zon like the run­ning lights of emi­grant ships, slung from tall masts and burn­ing brightly.

Our stars come from Ire­land in glit­ter­ing fleets. Twice each year the Milky Way swings over­head, arch­ing from north to south, and with it come the bright­est stars and con­stel­la­tions of the year. In sum­mer comes the Swan and the Eagle, and the tri­an­gle of bright stars, Vega, Deneb and Altair. Now, at Christ­mas­time, arrives the sec­ond fleet, the stars of win­ter. Here is Ori­on, with red Betel­geuse and blue-white Rigel. Here is Capel­la and the stars of Tau­rus the Bull, and the twin­kling clus­ter of the Pleiades. The Gem­i­ni twins, Cas­tor and Pol­lux, ascent from the hori­zon, soon fol­lowed by Can­is Major and Minor. No star is brighter than Sir­ius, the white flag­ship of Can­is Major. Sud­den­ly the skies are ablaze with stars.

Solstice celebrations

Many of the reli­gions that grew up in the north­ern hemi­sphere cel­e­brate “feasts of lights” in Decem­ber. The Jew­ish cel­e­bra­tion of Chanukah last for eight days of the month, with a new can­dle lit in a spe­cial meno­rah on each day of the fes­ti­val. Can­dles (or these days elec­tric lights) also play an impor­tant role in the cel­e­bra­tion of the birth of Christ. The near-coin­ci­dence of these great feast with the win­ter sol­stice is prob­a­bly no acci­dent. The sun is now low in south­ern skies for those of us who live north of the equa­tor. Since pre­his­toric times, men and women have sought in prayer and rit­u­al to stanch the sun’s ebbing win­ter light. The his­tor­i­cal and reli­gious sig­nif­i­cance of Chanukah and Christ­mas are rein­forced by the nat­ur­al sym­bol­ism of the rekin­dling of the sun’s strength.

A glance at the east­ern hori­zon this star­ry night will sug­gest anoth­er nat­ur­al com­ple­ment for the “feast of lights.” The sky is ablaze with night’s can­dles, the lumi­nous win­ter con­stel­la­tions. The Christ­mas feast of stars and lights is mir­rored in the sky.

No star real or imag­ined is more famous than the Christ­mas star the Magi fol­lowed to Beth­le­hem. “Lo, the star they had seen in the east went before them, till it came and stood over where the young child was.” Was there a real Christ­mas star, and if so, what was it?

There have been many the­o­ries. The Star of Beth­le­hem might have been a super­no­va, a dying star that in its death throes briefly flared with an excep­tion­al bright­ness. Or per­haps the star was a comet, hang­ing low on the west­ern hori­zon, beck­on­ing the Wise Men from the east. There is no inde­pen­dent evi­dence for either hypothesis.

A triple conjunction

Jesus was prob­a­bly born some­time between 7 B.C. when Augus­tus sent out his tax­a­tion decree, and 4 B.C. when Herod died. Dur­ing that peri­od there is at least one sure can­di­date for the Star of Beth­le­hem. In Feb­ru­ary of 6 B.C. occurred an unusu­al con­junc­tion of Mars, Jupiter and Sat­urn, a dra­mat­ic group­ing that hap­pens once every 800 years. These three plan­ets blaz­ing and danc­ing on the west­ern hori­zon might have seemed, to a less incred­u­lous gen­er­a­tion, the omen of a great event. They stood togeth­er in Pisces, south of the Great Square of Pega­sus, and shep­herds tend­ing flocks at night or Magi pon­der­ing the stars from a desert para­pet could hard­ly have failed to won­der about such star­ry lights beck­on­ing westward.

The stars go west. Watch tonight as the stars of Ori­on rise from the Atlantic and sail west­ward. The stars go west like young men, like the Union Pacif­ic, like dust­bowl Okies. The stars go west like New Eng­land hill farm­ers, like 49ers, like the fol­low­ers of Brigham Young. The go west like…like Irish­men. The stars cross from Ire­land in five hours, faster than a jet, twen­ty times faster than a lin­er, a hun­dred times faster than the “cof­fin ships” of the time of the famine. How so many stars sail out of a sky as small as the sky of Ire­land is a mystery.

The stars of 6 B.C. and the triple con­junc­tion of Mars, Jupiter and Sat­urn moved west to Judea and set upon the qui­et rooftops of Beth­le­hem. “And behold, an angel of the Lord stood by them and the Glo­ry of God shone round about them.” Had we been shep­herds, per­haps we too would have feared exceed­ing­ly. Had we been Magi, per­haps we too would have mount­ed camels and fol­lowed west­ward, seek­ing the Babe who would bring the peace of the star­ry night, seek­ing that per­fect peace that waits beyond the west­ern hori­zon for men of good will.

Share this Musing: