We’re studying our thinking

We’re studying our thinking

Photo by Milad Fakurian on Unsplash

Originally published 21 November 2000

It is not easy to live in that con­tin­u­ous aware­ness of things which alone is true liv­ing,” writes the nat­u­ral­ist Joseph Wood Krutch. And, of course, he is right. Our brains are sep­a­rat­ed from the world by a per­me­able mem­brane. Atten­tion flows out­ward. Sense impres­sions flow inwards. Of this two-way traf­fic we cre­ate a soul.

At this moment, as I sit at my desk, I try to be aware. Sun­light streams across my com­put­er key­board; eight min­utes ago these pho­tons were on the sur­face of the sun. A lady­bug crawls across the win­dow sill; why so many lady­bugs this time of the year? Out­side the win­dow, a con­gre­ga­tion of jays jab­ber in the trees.

Con­tin­u­ous aware­ness: It can be exhaust­ing. Which is why, I sup­pose, that some­times one just wish­es for the mind to go blank, the win­dows of the soul to close, the dark­ness to fall.

For­tu­nate­ly, the one thing we don’t have to attend to is aware­ness itself. The brain does its thing with­out the least bit of con­scious aware­ness on our part. And a good thing, too; if we had to attend to what is going on in the brain when we attend to the world, we’d…

We’d go nuts.

Noth­ing we know about in the uni­verse approach­es the com­plex­i­ty of the human brain. What is it? A vast spi­der web of neu­rons, cells with a thou­sand octo­pus-like arms, called den­drites. The den­drites reach out and make con­tact at their tips with the den­drites of oth­er cells, at junc­tions called synapses.

A hun­dred bil­lion neu­rons in the human brain, with an aver­age of 1,000 den­drites each. A hun­dred tril­lion octo­pus arms touch­ing like fin­ger­tips, and each synapse exquis­ite­ly con­trolled by the cells them­selves, strength­en­ing or weak­en­ing the con­tact, build­ing webs of inter­linked cells that are knowl­edge, mem­o­ry, con­scious­ness, self.

A hun­dred bil­lion neu­rons. That’s more brain cells than there are grains of salt in 1,000 one-pound box­es of salt. A room­ful of salt grains, floor to ceil­ing. Each in con­tact with hun­dreds, thou­sands, or tens of thou­sands of oth­ers. The con­tacts flick­er­ing with vari­able strength. Con­tin­u­ous­ly. Uncon­scious­ly. Nev­er ceas­ing. Remem­ber­ing. For­get­ting. Feel­ing joy. Feel­ing pain. Think­ing. Speak­ing. Lift­ing a foot, mov­ing it for­ward, putting it down again. Flick­er­ing. A hun­dred tril­lion flick­er­ing synapses.

Just think­ing about it is draining.

Neu­ro­sci­en­tists are busy try­ing to fig­ure it all out. Some folks would say that bring­ing the scruti­ny of sci­ence to bear upon the human soul is the height of pre­sump­tion. Oth­ers would say that the more we learn about what makes our brains tick, the more we stand in awe at the mys­tery of soul.

The sheer com­plex­i­ty of the human brain makes any ade­quate descrip­tion a daunt­ing task. Which is why some neu­ro­sci­en­tists choose to work with sim­pler organ­isms — sea snails, for exam­ple — to get a grip on the basic struc­ture and chemistry.

In recent years, new scan­ning tech­nolo­gies enable neu­ro­sci­en­tists to watch live human brains at work. Active neur­al regions flick­er on the screens of com­put­er mon­i­tors as sub­jects think, speak, recite poems, do math. Con­tin­u­ous aware­ness, dis­played on the screen of a scan­ning mon­i­tor, can look like a grass fire explod­ing across a prairie.

Still oth­er sci­en­tists attempt to mod­el the brain in sil­i­con, build­ing elec­tron­ic cir­cuits called neur­al net­works that mim­ic the activ­i­ty of the brain as it cre­ates con­stant­ly chang­ing webs of neu­rons. So far, no elec­tron­ic net­work begins to approach the com­plex­i­ty of the human brain, but the time is not far off when sil­i­con brains will rival fleshy ones. Just try­ing to make it hap­pen teach­es us a lot about how human brains work.

Per­haps the most excit­ing research is that of the sci­en­tists who study the bio­chem­istry of human neu­rons: How do the cells reg­u­late synap­tic con­nec­tions to build new neur­al webs? A [2000] issue of the jour­nal Sci­ence had a spe­cial sec­tion out­lin­ing advances in neur­al biochemistry.

The big sur­prise is just how much of the “think­ing” of neu­rons is done by the den­drites, those hun­dreds of spi­dery arms that con­nect neu­rons to one anoth­er. DNA in a neu­ron’s nucle­us sends mes­sen­ger RNA down along the den­drites to active synaps­es, where they are trans­lat­ed into pro­teins that reg­u­late the strength of synap­tic con­nec­tions. Tiny pro­tein fac­to­ries in the den­drites are appar­ent­ly key to learn­ing and memory.

Once the reg­u­la­tion of these pro­tein fac­to­ries is under­stood, drugs that ame­lio­rate some kinds of hered­i­tary men­tal retar­da­tion might be pos­si­ble. As will drugs that help all of us to learn and remem­ber. Are we ready for “smart pills?”

What all this amounts to is aware­ness of aware­ness. For the first time in the his­to­ry of con­scious­ness, the machin­ery of aware­ness has been turned on itself. As neu­ro­sci­en­tists will attest, think­ing about think­ing is not easy. Thank God we don’t have to think about think­ing to think.

Share this Musing: