Universal harmonies

Universal harmonies

“Saint Cecilia and an Angel“ by Orazio Gentileschi and Giovanni Lanfranco

Originally published 19 November 1990

Late night, can­dle­light, bot­tle of wine. Out­side, the stars of Ori­on high in the sky. Mars blazes bright­ly between the horns of Tau­rus. The Pleiades twin­kle. On the stereo, a favorite piece of music, Hen­ry Pur­cel­l’s Ode on St. Cecil­i­a’s Day 1692.

The over­ture begins in oboes and trum­pets, fol­lowed by a live­ly dance of strings. Then a duet of strings and oboes. The bass soloist intones “Hail! Hail bright Cecil­ia, Hail, Hail,” and the cho­rus joins in.

St. Cecil­ia is the tra­di­tion­al patroness of music. Long before Amer­i­cans invent­ed Turkey Day, her feast, Novem­ber 22nd, was cel­e­brat­ed with melody and song. On St. Cecil­i­a’s Day, 1692, music-lov­ing Lon­don­ers gath­ered at Sta­tion­er’s Hall to hear a pro­gram of new choral music by the most admired Eng­lish com­pos­er of the day, the roy­al organ­ist Hen­ry Pur­cell (with words by the cler­gy­man-poet Nicholas Brady). By all accounts the con­cert was a stun­ning suc­cess, with the com­pos­er him­self singing the alto solo “’Tis nature’s voice.”

A can­dle sput­ters, the cat curls up in her favorite chair. Tis Nature’s voice,” the alto sings of music, “thro’ all the mov­ing wood, of crea­tures under­stood, the uni­ver­sal tongue… In unseen chains, it does the fan­cy bind.”

Nature’s voice. The uni­ver­sal tongue. The words are very much in tune with Pur­cel­l’s time, and espe­cial­ly with the begin­ning of the last decade of Pur­cel­l’s cen­tu­ry. Only a few years ear­li­er, in 1687, Isaac New­ton had pub­lished what many con­sid­er the great­est sci­en­tif­ic book of all time, The Math­e­mat­i­cal Prin­ci­ples of Nat­ur­al Phi­los­o­phy, bet­ter known from the abbre­vi­a­tion of its Latin name as the Prin­cip­ia. In the book, New­ton pro­posed an unseen force — grav­i­ty — act­ing upon all objects in the uni­verse, bind­ing the plan­ets in their cours­es, bid­ding the tides to ebb and flow, guid­ing the fall of the apple from the tree — a uni­ver­sal harmony.

Mathematical rule

Pur­cell can hard­ly have been unaware of New­ton’s great work. He was an acquain­tance of the archi­tect Christo­pher Wren, who was him­self a friend of Edmund Hal­ley, Robert Hooke, Robert Boyle, Isaac New­ton, and oth­ers of a cir­cle of sci­en­tif­ic genius­es who togeth­er helped cre­ate mod­ern sci­ence. It is not improb­a­ble that some of these men were in the audi­ence at Sta­tion­er’s Hall for the 1692 per­for­mance of Pur­cel­l’s St. Cecil­ia ode.

New­ton’s Prin­cip­ia cre­at­ed a sen­sa­tion among the Lon­don intel­li­gentsia. Here was con­vinc­ing proof that the world was ruled by math­e­mat­i­cal laws, not by the whims of gods. The laws of grav­i­ty and motion bound all things with unseen chains. In New­ton’s the­o­ry, sci­en­tists of the late-17th cen­tu­ry believed they heard the voice of nature’s uni­ver­sal tongue.

A late moon ris­es, flood­ing the room with milky light. Sopra­no and bass voic­es begin one of the most beau­ti­ful of Pur­cel­l’s choral move­ments, “Soul of the World.” Altos and tenors take up the lyric, weav­ing togeth­er a per­fect hymn in praise of music:

Soul of the world, inspired by thee, the jar­ring, jar­ring seeds of mat­ter did dis­agree. Thou didst the scat­ter’d atoms bind, which by thy laws of true pro­por­tion joined. Made up of var­i­ous parts, one per­fect harmony.”

It is not hard to detect the spir­it of New­ton mov­ing in these lines. Pur­cell was not the first to describe nature’s scat­tered parts bound into a har­mo­nious whole by the pow­er of music. The idea orig­i­nat­ed with Pythago­ras, 2,000 years ear­li­er. Johannes Kepler, New­ton’s pre­de­ces­sor, strug­gled all his life to dis­cov­er the musi­cal har­monies that guid­ed the plan­ets in their orbits. Kepler’s laws of plan­e­tary motion were the basis for New­ton’s work.

What most impressed Pur­cel­l’s con­tem­po­raries about New­ton’s achieve­ment was its com­plete­ness. From a hand­ful of sim­ple math­e­mat­i­cal laws New­ton derived the orbits of comets, the motion of the moon, the sweep of the plan­ets in their cours­es, the flight of earth­ly pro­jec­tiles. This all-embrac­ing har­mo­ny of stars and atoms finds expres­sion in Pur­cel­l’s ode. An andante in oboes, then the sopra­no soloist sings: “Thou tun’st the world, this world below, the spheres above, who in heav­en­ly round to their own music move.”

A hinge of history

Music and math­e­mat­ics have much in com­mon, but sel­dom has music so explic­it­ly cap­tured the spir­it of sci­en­tif­ic achieve­ment as in Pur­cel­l’s com­po­si­tion for St. Cecil­i­a’s Day, 1692. The music rap­tur­ous­ly cel­e­brates what Hal­ley, in his prefa­to­ry poem to the Prin­cip­ia, called “the Laws which God, fram­ing the uni­verse, set not aside but made the fixed foun­da­tions of his work.”

The Prin­cip­ia was a hinge of his­to­ry, a tri­umph of law over mir­a­cle, of rea­son over sub­servience to chance. New­ton con­vinc­ing­ly demon­strat­ed a truth that would trans­form civ­i­liza­tion: Nature is ruled by math­e­mat­i­cal har­monies, and the har­monies are dis­cov­er­able by the human mind.

Eye­lids droop­ing, can­dles gut­ter­ing. Out­side, Ori­on leans into its west­ern set­ting. The bass soloist begins a mag­nif­i­cent song in praise of the organ, the king of musi­cal instru­ments, which is also a song of praise for the uni­verse revealed by New­ton: “Won­drous, won­drous, won­drous machine.”

Share this Musing: