Thus we behold a deadly beauty

Thus we behold a deadly beauty

Mycobacterium tuberculosis • CDC/ Dr. Ray Butler; Janice Carr (Public Domain)

Originally published 28 September 1998

On the evening of March 24, 1882, an unknown coun­try doc­tor deliv­ered one of the most impor­tant sci­en­tif­ic lec­tures of all time to the Phys­i­o­log­i­cal Soci­ety of Berlin. The audi­ence includ­ed some of Ger­many’s most emi­nent sci­en­tists and physi­cians, who lis­tened intent­ly as small, bespec­ta­cled Robert Koch drew their atten­tion to the table in front of him, where he had pre­pared glass slides of ani­mal and human tis­sue for exam­i­na­tion under the microscope.

Now — under the micro­scope the struc­tures of the ani­mal tis­sues, such as the nucle­us and its break­down prod­ucts, are brown, while the tuber­cle bac­te­ria are a beau­ti­ful blue,” he said.

Blue because of a new method of stain­ing devel­oped by Koch that revealed what no one had seen before. There, under the micro­scope, were micro­scop­i­cal­ly-small, pick­le-shaped bac­te­ria, the infec­tious agent of tuber­cu­lo­sis, mankind’s most per­sis­tent ene­my, glis­ten­ing the col­or of a trop­ic sea.

Koch’s audi­ence knew they were par­tic­i­pat­ing in an his­toric moment. The 17th-cen­tu­ry writer John Bun­yan had called tuber­cu­lo­sis “the cap­tain of all the men of death.” The dis­ease wreaked its ter­ri­ble toll through­out the ages, at least as far back as the Neolith­ic, among all peo­ples, on all con­ti­nents. In the late 19th cen­tu­ry, it was feared that tuber­cu­lo­sis might destroy Euro­pean civilization.

Unlike bubon­ic plague, which in the Mid­dle Ages swept through Europe in short, swift, killing fren­zies, tuber­cu­lo­sis burned with a steady, con­sum­ing flame. Its ancient name was con­sump­tion — a telling descrip­tion for the way the dis­ease slow­ly but sure­ly wast­ed away infect­ed indi­vid­u­als and entire populations.

Vast­ly more peo­ple har­bor the tuber­cu­lo­sis bac­te­ria than devel­op the dis­ease; per­haps as many as one-third of the world’s pop­u­la­tion is infect­ed. Gen­er­al­ly, the bacil­lus resides in its human host in a dor­mant or qui­es­cent state, repro­duc­ing at a leisure­ly pace, caus­ing lit­tle harm. Only when the body’s immune sys­tem is weak­ened — by mal­nu­tri­tion, for exam­ple — does the pathogen flourish.

Koch’s dis­cov­ery of the cause of the dis­ease was the first step in a long and ulti­mate­ly suc­cess­ful search for a cure. By the ear­ly 1950s, two drugs, strep­to­mycin and para-aminos­al­i­cylic acid (PAS), had proved their abil­i­ty in com­bi­na­tion to knock out the disease.

But the vic­to­ry was­n’t con­sol­i­dat­ed. Today, the tuber­cu­lo­sis bac­te­ria—Mycobac­teri­um tuber­cu­lo­sis—con­tin­ues to take more vic­tims than any oth­er infec­tious agent. It has evolved new drug-resis­tant forms. And it has forged a dead­ly alliance with the HIV virus, which weak­ens the body’s nat­ur­al defens­es against the tuber­cu­lo­sis bacilli.

A beau­ti­ful blue! As Koch observed this dev­as­tat­ing killer for the first time, he saw beau­ty. Beau­ty and death are not infre­quent com­pan­ions in the quest for knowledge.

Think of Marie Curie’s spec­i­men of radi­um, col­lect­ed through years of exhaust­ing work, glow­ing with an ethe­re­al light in her dark­ened lab­o­ra­to­ry; the stuff would even­tu­al­ly kill her.

Think of the ghast­ly beau­ty of the mush­room cloud at Alam­ogor­do, ris­ing heav­en­ward, soon to vis­it oblit­er­a­tion on two Japan­ese cities.

Think of the beau­ty of the Chal­lenger space­craft, climb­ing on a pil­lar of fire, explod­ing like a spec­tac­u­lar fire­works; it car­ried sev­en brave astro­nauts to eternity.

Beau­ty is noth­ing but the begin­ning of ter­ror,” wrote the Ger­man poet Rain­er Maria Rilke — and so it has often been with the Janus-faced agents of death, includ­ing tuber­cu­lo­sis. In the imag­i­na­tion of roman­tic poets, com­posers and writ­ers, tuber­cu­lo­sis con­ferred a kind a spir­i­tu­al beau­ty on its vic­tims: Mimi in La bohème, Alphon­sine Plessis in La travi­a­ta, Lit­tle Blos­som in David Cop­per­field. A char­ac­ter in Thomas Man­n’s Mag­ic Moun­tain could say with somber con­vic­tion that the dis­ease was “only love transformed.”

And now tuber­cu­lo­sis has shown us anoth­er facet of its per­verse love­li­ness. Its genome has been com­plete­ly sequenced — that is, all 4.4 mil­lion chem­i­cal base pairs along its DNA dou­ble helix have been deter­mined. A map of the bac­teri­um’s pro­tein-build­ing genes was dis­played as a five-foot-long fold-out in the June 11th [1998] issue of the jour­nal Nature.

The map is beau­ti­ful­ly col­ored, with a dif­fer­ent hue for each func­tion­al cat­e­go­ry of pro­teins: metab­o­lism, res­pi­ra­tion, cell wall, vir­u­lence, and so on. The map resem­bled noth­ing so much as the score of a great sym­pho­ny; in this case, the sym­pho­ny of life.

What we see is not the face of evil — the cap­tain of all the men of death — but the exquis­ite chem­i­cal dynam­ic that all life shares. The sequenced genome of Mycobac­teri­um tuber­cu­lo­sis rep­re­sents an impres­sive sci­en­tif­ic achieve­ment; it is also beau­ti­ful to behold, an atom­ic music built into the very fab­ric of the world.

In Nicholas Nick­le­by, Charles Dick­ens described tuber­cu­lo­sis as a “dis­ease in which death and life are so strange­ly blend­ed, that death takes the glow and hue of life.” The same might be said for the genome of Mycobac­teri­um tuber­cu­lo­sis as it is dis­played in the fold-out pages of Nature—a les­son in the mor­tal and amoral dynam­ic of evolution.

With­out death there is no life. With­out ter­ror there is no beauty.

Share this Musing: