The unsimple apple

The unsimple apple

Photo by DrKontogianniIVF

Originally published 12 December 1988

I have a col­league, a physi­cist, who tells his stu­dents, “If it’s not sim­ple, it’s not physics.”

He does not mean that physics is easy. He means that physics is the study of things sim­ple enough to be described math­e­mat­i­cal­ly. The rota­tion of a galaxy is sim­ple. The pro­duc­tion of ener­gy by a star is sim­ple. The fall of an apple from a tree is sim­ple. The apple is not simple.

Physics is sim­ple; biol­o­gy is not sim­ple. A sin­gle liv­ing cell is vast­ly more intri­cate than a star. Even the sim­plest life process­es seem mir­a­cles to the physi­cist. And no life process seems more mirac­u­lous (to this physi­cist) than the fer­til­iza­tion of an egg by a sperm.

Miraculous process

At birth, the ovaries of a female human con­tain sev­er­al mil­lion eggs in an ear­ly stage of devel­op­ment. When the female reach­es sex­u­al matu­ri­ty, devel­op­ment of the eggs resumes. About 300 or 400 eggs may reach matu­ri­ty and are released, usu­al­ly one at a time, each month after puber­ty. Each egg is large, as cells go, and con­tains a sin­gle set of chro­mo­somes — about three feet of DNA select­ed from the moth­er’s genet­ic endowment.

The pro­duc­tion of male sperm begins at puber­ty and con­tin­ues through­out sex­u­al matu­ri­ty. Three or four hun­dred mil­lion sperm are present in the ejac­u­late of a nor­mal adult male. A sperm is a tiny DNA tor­pe­do, equipped with a pro­peller at the back and an inva­sion appa­ra­tus at the front. Each sperm con­tains a sin­gle set of chro­mo­somes — again, about three feet of DNA select­ed from the father’s genes.

Of the hun­dreds of mil­lions of sperm in a typ­i­cal ejac­u­late, only one will fuse with the egg and ini­ti­ate a new life. But fer­til­iza­tion is not a blind race which sets one sperm against all oth­ers. A mass attack by sperm is essen­tial for suc­cess­ful pen­e­tra­tion of the egg. Nor is the egg a mere pas­sive receiv­er of the sper­m’s atten­tion. The egg plays a cru­cial role in orches­trat­ing a sequence of chem­i­cal events that must occur in pre­cise order.

Our cur­rent under­stand­ing of the fer­til­iza­tion process in mam­mals is described in a remark­able arti­cle by Paul Was­sar­man in the Decem­ber [1988] issue of Sci­en­tif­ic Amer­i­can. Was­sar­man, a leader in elu­ci­dat­ing the details of fer­til­iza­tion, is chair­man of the depart­ment of cell and devel­op­men­tal biol­o­gy at the Roche Insti­tute of Mol­e­c­u­lar Biol­o­gy in Nut­ley, N.J. His group has worked most­ly on fer­til­iza­tion in mice, but the process is believed to be sim­i­lar in oth­er mammals.

The crux of the fer­til­iza­tion process begins when sperm reach the out­er lay­er of the egg, a glassy mem­brane called the zona pel­lu­ci­da. Three things must now hap­pen. Only sperm of the same species as the egg must be allowed to bind to the egg. A reac­tion must occur that allows the sperm to pen­e­trate the zona pel­lu­ci­da. And final­ly, when a sin­gle sperm has reached the inte­ri­or of the egg, all oth­ers must be pre­vent­ed from entering.

A biological security system

The zona pel­lu­ci­da has some­times been viewed by biol­o­gists as a mere imped­i­ment to fer­til­iza­tion. Was­sar­man sug­gests that this appar­ent­ly pas­sive out­er enve­lope func­tions as a “sophis­ti­cat­ed bio­log­i­cal secu­ri­ty sys­tem,” chem­i­cal­ly con­trol­ling the entry of sperm to egg.

The zona pel­lu­ci­da of mice eggs con­sists of just three kinds of mol­e­cules, called gly­co­pro­teins (chains of amino acids with attached sug­ars). One of these, labeled ZP3 by inves­ti­ga­tors, is appar­ent­ly the jack-of-all-trades in the fer­til­iza­tion process. Thou­sands of these mol­e­cules bind the thrash­ing sperm to the egg, but only sperm with egg-bind­ing pro­teins on their heads that match the ZP3 like lock and key. ZP3 then induces a chem­i­cal reac­tion that allows the bound sperm to worm their way through the zona pel­lu­ci­da. And final­ly, chem­i­cal changes in ZP3, ini­ti­at­ed at the instant a sperm fus­es with egg, ren­der the zona pel­lu­ci­da imper­me­able to all but the first suc­cess­ful invader.

A scan­ning-elec­tron micro­graph accom­pa­ny­ing Was­sar­man’s arti­cle shows mouse sperm attach­ing them­selves to a micro­scop­ic glass bead that has been coat­ed with ZP3 from a mouse egg. If sperm can be fooled into lav­ish­ing their atten­tion on a glass bead, they might also be fooled into ignor­ing eggs. Stud­ies of the chem­istry of gly­co­pro­teins might con­ceiv­ably lead to new meth­ods of con­tra­cep­tion, and to new ther­a­pies for cer­tain kinds of infertility.

The sci­en­tif­ic detec­tive work described in Was­sar­man’s arti­cle makes fas­ci­nat­ing read­ing. The exper­i­men­tal tech­niques are as sub­tle and quan­ti­ta­tive as any in physics. The results of the exper­i­ments are, in Was­sar­man’s words, sur­pris­ing­ly sim­ple: For mam­mals, a sin­gle sug­ar-laced pro­tein, ZP3, is the instru­ment by which egg and sperm achieve their spec­tac­u­lar moment of truth.

With the fusion of egg and sperm a new life begins. The fer­til­ized cell divides, pro­duc­ing two daugh­ter cells, each with a full com­ple­ment of DNA — six feet of genet­ic code, half from each par­ent. These cells divide again, then again and again, and genes in dif­fer­ent cells begin to express them­selves in dif­fer­ent ways, until an organ­ism is formed made up of a tril­lion high­ly-dif­fer­en­ti­at­ed cells, each with an exact six-foot copy of the orig­i­nal DNA, a chem­i­cal blue­print that sub­stan­tial­ly deter­mines the bio­log­i­cal des­tiny of a sin­gle indi­vid­ual from con­cep­tion to death.

It may seem a mir­a­cle, but the more we learn about the mol­e­c­u­lar chem­istry of life the sim­pler it seems — in the sense we say physics is sim­ple. Life is nei­ther mir­a­cle nor mag­ic. As the work of inves­ti­ga­tors like Was­sar­man and his col­leagues makes clear, life is a chem­i­cal dra­ma unfold­ing at the lev­el of pro­teins and DNA. Chem­i­cal reac­tions lend them­selves to exact descrip­tion. Some­day it may be pos­si­ble to say that an apple is no less “sim­ple” than an apple’s fall from a tree.

Share this Musing: