The quest for the flash

The quest for the flash

The green flash at sunrise • Photo by Luis Argerich (CC BY-NC 2.0)

Originally published 15 March 1999

EXUMA, Bahamas — Morn­ing. The sky most­ly clear to the far hori­zon, just a few wisps of cloud far out there over the sea where the sun will soon rise. The air is tinged pink, orange, and yel­low, like lay­ers of sug­ar icing on the turquoise sea.

Rays stream­ing upward — faint vees of light defin­ing the place where the sun will appear. I wait, as I have wait­ed in sim­i­lar cir­cum­stances for 34 years, at sun­rise and sun­set, over seas and deserts, on three con­ti­nents, in all sea­sons, north and south of the equa­tor. For the green flash.

I have wait­ed and watched so many times with­out suc­cess, that the wait­ing and watch­ing has become an end in itself, a qui­et time to expe­ri­ence the beau­ty of sun­rise or sun­set, a time to reflect upon all in the world that is inex­plic­a­ble, beyond our ken.

A kind of prayer to the Deus abscon­di­tus—the hid­den God.

And now the disk of the sun bub­bles up on the hori­zon. And sud­den­ly I am star­tled as the top of the disk turns emer­ald green — a bril­liant, blaz­ing col­or like none I have seen before. The green flash.

The object of all that search­ing, found at last.

The green flash is a momen­tary ray of col­or that some­times appears at the top of the sun’s disk as it ris­es or sets on a dis­tant hori­zon. The flash is caused by refrac­tion (bend­ing) of sun­light as it pass­es through the Earth­’s atmos­phere. The atmos­phere acts like a prism, spread­ing the sun’s light into a spec­trum, blue at the top, red at the bot­tom. Blue light is effec­tive­ly removed from the spec­trum by the great thick­ness of air we are look­ing through at sun­rise or sun­set (which is why the sun appears red at those times). When most of the red, orange, and yel­low light in the sun’s spec­trum is blocked by the hori­zon we see what’s left of the spec­trum — the flash of green.

My long quest for the green flash began when I read an arti­cle in Sci­en­tif­ic Amer­i­can in 1965 by the astronomer D.J.K. O’Con­nell of the Vat­i­can Obser­va­to­ry. The effect described by O’Con­nell seemed so evanes­cent, so unex­pect­ed, that I deter­mined to see it. Lit­tle did I know then how elu­sive it would be.

Until O’Con­nel­l’s research it was wide­ly assumed that the green flash was a sub­jec­tive phe­nom­e­na or an opti­cal illu­sion. Reti­nal fatigue was com­mon­ly held to be the “cause.” After look­ing into a bright­ly col­ored light our eyes get tired, and upon look­ing away we see the com­pli­men­ta­ry col­or; so, accord­ing to this the­o­ry, after look­ing for a while at the set­ting sun, which is red, we tend to see the com­pli­men­ta­ry col­or, green, when the sun drops below the hori­zon. But reti­nal fatigue does not explain why the flash pre­cedes the sun at sunrise.

O’Con­nel­l’s work proved the sub­jec­tive the­o­ries false. He suc­ceed­ed in obtain­ing col­or pho­tographs of the flash. The pho­tographs were dif­fi­cult to make. The band of col­or to be cap­tured on film is nar­row and fleet­ing. But the evi­dence on the film was indis­putable. The green flash is not an arti­fact of the human eye. In pho­to­graph after pho­to­graph, the sun’s disk is capped with a strip of emer­ald green.

The green flash can only be seen if the hori­zon is sharply defined and the atmos­phere free from haze, con­di­tions most com­mon­ly encoun­tered in the trop­ics, on coasts, in high moun­tains, or in deserts. When­ev­er I was in such places, I made sure to be watch­ing at sun­rise and sunset.

Four­teen years ago I men­tioned my search for the green flash in this col­umn, and again sev­en years ago. Sev­er­al read­ers sent pho­tographs. Oth­ers described obser­va­tions of the flash from such unex­ot­ic venues as Cape Cod and the coast of Maine. One per­son invit­ed me to his vaca­tion home on a Caribbean isle where he claimed the flash was vis­i­ble almost every evening (I did­n’t go).

Since we start­ed vis­it­ing this trop­ic island sev­er­al years ago I have made it my busi­ness to antic­i­pate sun­rise. I have seen stars fade in auro­ral light. I have seen Venus and Mer­cury shin­ing in the dawn. I have seen satel­lites, mete­ors, clouds of every shape and col­or, and cres­cent moons that were eye­lash thin. But nev­er the green flash. Until now.

In one of those ear­li­er columns on the flash, I said that I was not alto­geth­er sor­ry that my search had been unsuc­cess­ful. I quot­ed Antoine de Saint-Exupéry’s Lit­tle Prince: “What makes the desert beau­ti­ful is that some­where it hides a well.”

The green flash was my hid­den well.

So I am a lit­tle dis­ap­point­ed to have seen it, but glad too. “What’s the use of pray­ing if God does not answer?” asked the medieval mys­tic Julian of Nor­wich. If wait­ing and watch­ing for the green flash for 34 years was a kind of prayer, I’ve had my answer.

Share this Musing: