Meaningful messes

Meaningful messes

Packrat midden at Joshua Tree National Park • Photo by Robb Hannawacker (Public Domain)

Originally published 15 October 1990

Pack­rats pack. Pale­on­tol­o­gists unpack. Out in the deserts of the Amer­i­can West pale­on­tol­o­gists unpack pack­rats’ packs.

Let me unpack that tongue-twister.

Cli­mate is on every­one’s mind’s these days. Hard­ly a day goes by that we don’t hear dire pre­dic­tions of green­house warm­ing, ice caps melt­ing, sea lev­els ris­ing, dust bowls form­ing. The truth is this: No one is quite sure whether we’re in for an abnor­mal­ly warm future, more of the same, or anoth­er ice age.

But if the future is uncer­tain, past cli­mates can be recon­struct­ed with some mod­est degree of cer­tain­ty. The past can be a crys­tal ball to the future.

Sci­en­tists who study past cli­mates find clues in extra­or­di­nary places. Plant spores and pollen in deep bogs. Dust and air bub­bles in the Green­land and Antarc­tic ice caps. Fos­sil plank­ton from sed­i­ments on the floor of the sea. Fos­silized tree rings. Coral reefs. Any­where, in fact, where some­thing has accu­mu­lat­ed with time and has endured rel­a­tive­ly undisturbed.

That’s where pack­rats come in. Pack­rats accu­mu­late. And because of a quirk of pack­rat behav­ior, pack­rat accu­mu­la­tions can endure for ages.

The pack­rats I’m talk­ing about are cute lit­tle crea­tures, with big Mick­ey Mouse eyes and ears. They range from the Arc­tic Cir­cle in Cana­da to Nicaragua. It is the pack­rats of the south­west­ern Unit­ed States that have been of most inter­est to paleontologists.

Onto the scrap heap

Pack­rats col­lect food. They col­lect mate­r­i­al to build their dens. They drag home sticks, cac­tus spines, plant frag­ments of all sorts, mam­mal bones, dung, insects, almost any­thing in fact that they can get their paws on. And the impor­tant thing is this: They col­lect more than what they use. What they don’t need they toss out the door.

Into a pile.

Out­side every pack­rat den is a mid­den — a refuse dump, a garbage heap.

The pack­rat mid­den is a big pile of plant and ani­mal parts col­lect­ed from the neigh­bor­hood. Upon this pile the pack­rat is inclined to relieve itself. Crys­tal­lized pack­rat urine, called amber­at, sat­u­rates the mid­den, encas­ing it in a tough amber-like sheath.

Urea, in pack­rat urine, has the chem­i­cal effect of mum­mi­fy­ing plant frag­ments in the mid­den, much as pack­ing them in salt would do.

Also, the amber­at repels ter­mites and bee­tles who might bur­row into and oth­er­wise dis­turb the mid­den. For all of these rea­sons, pack­rat mid­dens can be won­der­ful­ly endur­ing. They can endure for thou­sands of years.

Enter, the paleontologist.

What is a pack­rat mid­den, after all, but a care­ful­ly col­lect­ed muse­um-qual­i­ty assort­ment of fos­silized flo­ra and fau­na sort­ed by age and tidi­ly pre­served. The pale­on­tol­o­gist need only drag mid­dens home to have a record of changes in plant and ani­mal com­mu­ni­ties extend­ing over mil­len­nia — and, by infer­ence, a record of cli­mate change.

The defin­i­tive work on inter­pret­ing pack­rat mid­dens has just been pub­lished by the Uni­ver­si­ty of Ari­zona Press: Pack­rat Mid­dens: The Last 40,000 Years of Biot­ic Change. Yes, 40,000 years! Some pack­rat mid­dens have last­ed that long.

What we learn is that 40,000 years ago the cli­mate in the Amer­i­can South­west was very dif­fer­ent than today. Deserts were less exten­sive. Forests of spruce, fir, and pine grew at low­er ele­va­tions. Ani­mals and insects had dif­fer­ent ranges. All in response to the ice-age glacia­tion of north­ern North Amer­i­ca. When the ice began melt­ing about 15,000 years ago, plant and ani­mal com­mu­ni­ties changed too. The changes are doc­u­ment­ed in pack­rat middens.

Eclectic mess

Ecol­o­gists who study present-day envi­ron­ments have the advan­tage of detail — every rat whisker and cac­tus seed can be observed in sharp focus — but they see only a snap­shot in the unfold­ing saga of bio­log­i­cal and cli­mat­ic change. Pale­on­tol­o­gists who study fos­sil flo­ra and fau­na see the entire movie, so to speak, but each frame is blurred by the pas­sage of time. The fur­ther back in time the sci­en­tists probe the blur­ri­er their fos­sil images become.

Pack­rat mid­dens will be espe­cial­ly blur­ry if their mak­ers were selec­tive. But the pack­rats who live in Amer­i­can deserts today are reas­sur­ing­ly eclec­tic in what they col­lect, so there’s rea­son to believe that their ice-age ances­tors also pre­pared rep­re­sen­ta­tive sam­ples of their envi­ron­ments. The fos­silized mid­dens are about as good a record of past habi­tats and cli­mates as sci­en­tists could hope to find.

The les­son of the pack­rat mid­dens is this: For a sci­en­tist, today’s trash heap can be tomor­row’s cache of treasure.

Share this Musing: