Does the world need smarter mice?

Does the world need smarter mice?

Image by Pixabay (Public Domain)

Originally published 20 September 1999

(With apolo­gies to E. B. White.)

When Mrs. Lit­tle’s adopt­ed son arrived at the fam­i­ly home in New York City, every­body noticed that he was not much big­ger than a mouse. The truth of the mat­ter is, he was a mouse. Mrs. Lit­tle named him Stu­art and Mr. Lit­tle made him a tiny bed out of four clothes­pins and a cig­a­rette box.

Stu­art was no ordi­nary mouse. He was adopt­ed from the lab­o­ra­to­ry of Pro­fes­sor Joe Tsien across the riv­er at Prince­ton Uni­ver­si­ty. Pro­fes­sor Tsien and col­leagues from MIT and Wash­ing­ton Uni­ver­si­ty had reared Stu­art as one of a spe­cial strain of genet­i­cal­ly engi­neered mice. Stu­art was smarter than the mice that lived in Mrs. Stu­ar­t’s pantry.

What the sci­en­tists did is this: They added extra copies of a spe­cial gene to nor­mal mouse embryos. This gene, called NR2B, helps make a pro­tein that con­trols the flow of chem­i­cal sig­nals between neu­rons in the brain. Extra pro­teins make it eas­i­er for the brain to store mem­o­ries. The genet­i­cal­ly mod­i­fied mice learn faster and remem­ber bet­ter than ordi­nary mice.

Stu­art Lit­tle looked like an ordi­nary mouse in almost every respect. He was about two inch­es high, and he had a mouse’s sharp nose, a mouse’s tail, and a mouse’s whiskers. But he lacked the pleas­ant, shy man­ner of a mouse. He was, in fact, inor­di­nate­ly fond of remind­ing every­one that he was “more intel­li­gent” than ordi­nary mice.

My good­ness,” said Mrs. Lit­tle. “Lit­tle Stu­art is cer­tain­ly pre­co­cious. Now, if only we can teach him to make his bed and hang his clothes up on his chair.”

Of course, Stu­art knew very well how to make his bed and hang up his clothes. He was, after all, no ordi­nary rodent. But he was also smart enough to know that he could get away with leav­ing his sheets rum­pled and his clothes heaped on the floor. “Genet­i­cal­ly-enhanced mice can’t be both­ered,” he thought smug­ly to himself.

The home of the Lit­tle fam­i­ly was a pleas­ant place near a park on the Upper East­side. Mr. and Mrs. Lit­tle were quite wealthy, which is why they could afford to adopt such a spe­cial mouse. Genet­i­cal­ly engi­neered mice don’t come cheap.

Per­haps some­day every­one will have mem­o­ry-enhanced chil­dren,” said Mr. Lit­tle to Mrs. Lit­tle. “But we are the first in our neigh­bor­hood,” he added with some pride. He imag­ined that some­day Stu­art might go to Prince­ton or MIT or Wash­ing­ton University.

But I do wish Stu­art would per­form his chores,” said Mrs. Lit­tle wistfully.

Mrs. Lit­tle owned a white cat named Snow­bell. Snow­bell was just an ordi­nary cat with­out any expen­sive engi­neered genes. Like most ordi­nary cats, he liked to laze in the sun and chase mice.

What a dull ani­mal you are,” said Stu­art to Snow­bell. “Did I tell you about my NR2B? The synaps­es in my brain are those of a mouse half my age. Why, I can run a maze in half the time it takes those sil­ly mice in the pantry.”

Oh God,” thought Snow­bell. “A gene bore.” He opened his big feline mouth and showed two rows of gleam­ing white teeth, sharp as needles.

Very nice,” said Stu­art, with obvi­ous sar­casm. “But who needs big sharp teeth when they have extra NR2B genes. Have you ever heard of a pro­tein called NMDA, which acts as a switch in the brain for mem­o­ry for­ma­tion? No? I thought not. Well, let me tell you, my brain may not be much larg­er than your teeth, but it’s pos­i­tive­ly swim­ming with NMDA.”

Mem­o­ry is not the same thing as intel­li­gence,” growled Snow­bell through gleam­ing teeth. “A com­put­er has lots of mem­o­ry, but I’ve nev­er seen a com­put­er that can move about the room to find a warm place in the sun.”

Bosh,” sniffed Stu­art. “What do cats know?” With a twitch of his nose and a haughty huff he marched off to nap in his rum­pled bed.

That after­noon a pret­ty lit­tle hen-bird, brown, with a streak of yel­low on her breast, showed up on Mrs. Lit­tle’s win­dowsill. She might have been a vireo or maybe a wren, but she came to stay. She hopped into Stu­ar­t’s room where he was lying in bed.

Hel­lo,” said Stu­art when he saw the bird. “I am Stu­art, a genet­i­cal­ly-engi­neered mouse, and I have the mem­o­ry of a mouse half my age. Who are you? Where did you come from?”

My name is Mar­ga­lo,” said the bird, soft­ly in a musi­cal voice. “I come from fields once tall with wheat, from pas­tures deep in fern and this­tle; I come from vales of mead­owsweet, and I love to whistle.”

Stu­art sat bolt upright in bed. “Say that again,” he whispered.

I come from fields once tall with wheat, from pas­tures deep in fern and this­tle; I come from vales of mead­owsweet, and I love to whis­tle,” chirped Margalo.

Stu­art did­n’t need a brain full of NMDA to rec­og­nize that this pret­ty hen-bird, brown, with yel­low-streaked breast and per­fect­ly nor­mal hen-bird genes was clev­er­er by far than he. “Per­haps true intel­li­gence is more than souped-up synaps­es,” he mused despon­dent­ly. He pulled the bed­clothes over his head and stayed in bed until a week from Thursday.

Share this Musing: