Can’t fight phobia even in paradise

Can’t fight phobia even in paradise

A Greater Antillean Boa • Photo by Jan P Zegarra (Public Domain)

Originally published 22 March 1999

EXUMA, Bahamas — Every par­adise has its snake, as Adam and Eve learned to their chagrin.

The fact that the sweet-talk­ing rep­tile was there at all means that Eden was­n’t every­thing it was cracked up to be. A par­adise with a snake was flawed even before Eve bit the apple by most peo­ple’s esti­ma­tion. Snakes are sure­ly the plan­et’s least pop­u­lar creature.

This Bahami­an par­adise has three rep­til­ian inhab­i­tants: the five-inch worm snake, the mid-sized brown rac­er, and the gar­gan­tu­an Antil­lean boa con­stric­tor.

I’ve been look­ing for a live boa ever since I start­ed com­ing to this island. I final­ly met one last week, sprawled across a wood­land path — six feet long and as big around as my arm. We regard­ed each oth­er with mutu­al curios­i­ty. I man­aged to get with­in spit­ting dis­tance before he turned tail and ran.

The Bahami­ans call the boa the fowl snake, pre­sum­ably because it is pur­port­ed to take chick­ens from the yard. I’ve heard it said by islanders that a fowl snake will take a baby from its cra­dle, but I don’t believe it for a minute. A no less pre­pos­ter­ous ver­sion is that a fowl snake will steal milk from a baby’s bot­tle. The crea­ture comes wrapped in demon­ic myths of every sort, as behooves the largest and creepi­est — although non-ven­omous — wild ani­mal on the island.

The same day that I encoun­tered the boa I also met a giant hairy ground spi­der — anoth­er first. These hand-sized mon­sters hunt most­ly at night, din­ing on such del­i­ca­cies as lizards and mice. Their bite is no more dan­ger­ous than a bee sting, but the one I met as I tramped though the woods scared me half to death. If that spi­der had been any­where clos­er to home I would have whacked it with a shovel.

The Bahami­an ground spi­der belongs to a fam­i­ly known as the hairy myga­lo­morphs, an appro­pri­ate­ly unat­trac­tive moniker for such an unat­trac­tive ani­mal, but every­one here calls them “taran­tu­las,” which tech­ni­cal­ly they aren’t. They call taran­tu­las “taran­tu­las” too, which is a source of some con­fu­sion. In any case, the hairy myga­lo­morph, with its eight eyes and eight legs is no more pop­u­lar than the boa.

I told my neigh­bor about see­ing a fowl snake and a “taran­tu­la.” She said, “I don’t like no crea­ture with more or less limbs than me.”

Har­vard biol­o­gist E. O. Wil­son would say she does­n’t have much choice in her adverse reac­tion to the boa and spi­der. It is all part of some­thing he calls bio­phil­ia, “love of life” — an innate emo­tion­al entan­gle­ment of human beings with oth­er liv­ing organisms.

Cer­tain­ly, the human brain evolved dur­ing the 99 per­cent of human his­to­ry dur­ing which our ances­tors lived as hunter/gatherers in a bio­log­i­cal­ly diverse envi­ron­ment. A residue of that long expe­ri­ence is hard­wired into our emo­tion­al cir­cuits, Wil­son believes, which is why we like to vis­it zoos and live in park-like envi­ron­ments sim­i­lar to the African savan­nas where our species had its infancy.

Part of bio­phil­ia might be more appro­pri­ate­ly called bio­pho­bia — an aver­sion to ani­mals or envi­ron­ments that once rep­re­sent­ed sig­nif­i­cant threats to human secu­ri­ty. These include, of course, snakes and spi­ders, both of which can be seri­ous­ly ven­omous. We have snakes and spi­ders on the brain, says Wil­son, and not only on the brain but also in the genes.

He goes so far as to draw a moral les­son: Oth­er species are our kin, both bio­log­i­cal­ly and — in the bio­phil­ia sense — psy­cho­log­i­cal­ly, and there­fore wor­thy of our affec­tion, respect and con­ser­va­tion. Allow­ing our vio­lent ten­den­cies to destroy a world in which the brain was assem­bled over mil­lions of years is a risky step, he says.

He may be right, but I won­der what the warm­ly bio­philic E. O. Wil­son would do if he found a hairy myga­lo­morph in his shoe closet.

Anoth­er unpop­u­lar crea­ture in these parts is the giant bat moth, dark brown, almost black, del­i­cate­ly mot­tled, with an eight-inch wingspan. We find them almost every evening plas­tered to the out­side of the win­dow screens, look­ing won­der­ful­ly diabolical.

Cubans call them bru­jas, “witch­es”, and believe they are the embod­ied spir­its of the dead. In the Bahamas, too, they are looked upon as unlucky and oth­er­world­ly. They are, of course, total­ly harm­less, and if they evoke a strong emo­tion­al reac­tion it is prob­a­bly because of their resem­blance to bats. Whether and why our almost uni­ver­sal fear of bats is bio­pho­bic remain to be seen.

Wil­son believes we will nev­er work out an appro­pri­ate rela­tion­ship with the oth­er species of this plan­et until we rec­og­nize the degree to which our emo­tion­al lives are shaped by human genetic/cultural coevo­lu­tion in inti­mate con­tact with crea­tures both ben­e­fi­cial and threat­en­ing. “Our spir­it is woven from it,” he says, “hope ris­es on its currents.”

And even now, as I write, the bat moth out­side my win­dow screen takes wing, ris­es on cur­rents of air, to fly, per­haps, to my neigh­bor’s house, where it will meet the emo­tion­al his­to­ry of our species in the form of a fatal splat with a rolled-up copy of yes­ter­day’s Nas­sau Tribune.

Share this Musing: