All the old sciences have starring roles

All the old sciences have starring roles

Photo by Elena Mozhvilo on Unsplash

Originally published 13 May 2003

When I was in high school many long years ago, the sci­ences were the basics — physics, chem­istry, biol­o­gy. Boys took physics (and went on to become engi­neers and auto­mo­bile mechan­ics), girls took biol­o­gy (and became nurs­es and home­mak­ers), and nobody took chem­istry if they could help it (except a few nerds who want­ed to make stink bombs).

These days the sci­ences are rather more jum­bled up, and stu­dents might encounter phys­i­cal chem­istry, bio­physics, bio­chem­istry, or any of many oth­er blend­ed spe­cial­ties. Gen­der in the sci­ence class­rooms is rather more jum­bled, too.

But, by and large, the old cat­e­gories stand: If you are going to orga­nize the sci­ences under a few prac­ti­cal head­ings, physics, chem­istry, and biol­o­gy are the best way to do it.

These cat­e­gories are not arbi­trary. In broad out­line, they cor­re­spond to how the uni­verse evolves in space and time.

The uni­verse began as pure physics, in an explo­sion from an infi­nite­ly hot seed of radi­ant ener­gy. Dur­ing the first tril­lion-tril­lion-tril­lionth of a sec­ond, mat­ter and anti­mat­ter flick­ered in and out of exis­tence. The fate of the uni­verse hung pre­car­i­ous­ly in the bal­ance; it might grow, or it might col­lapse back into nothingness.

Sud­den­ly it bal­looned to enor­mous size, in what cos­mol­o­gists call the infla­tion­ary epoch, bring­ing the first par­ti­cles of mat­ter — the quarks — into exis­tence. With­in a mil­lionth of a sec­ond, the rapid swelling ceased, and the quarks began to com­bine into pro­tons and neutrons.

The uni­verse con­tin­ued to expand and cool, but now at a more state­ly pace. With­in a few more min­utes, pro­tons and neu­trons com­bined to form the first atom­ic nuclei — hydro­gen and heli­um — but the uni­verse was still too hot for the nuclei to attract elec­trons and make atoms. Not until 300,000 years after the begin­ning did the first atoms appear.

In all of this, there was noth­ing of rel­e­vance to a chemist or biol­o­gist. Chem­istry could only begin when parts of the uni­verse had cooled suf­fi­cient­ly for atoms to cling togeth­er as mol­e­cules (but not so cold that every­thing is locked togeth­er in rock-hard solids). And biol­o­gy could only begin when the right kind of atoms — car­bon, nitro­gen, oxy­gen, phos­pho­rus, and sul­fur — had appeared on the scene.

The atoms of life were cooked up in stars by nuclear fusion and blast­ed into space when the stars died as super­novas. So, even after the era of chem­istry had begun, there were not yet the right ele­ments for bio­log­i­cal mol­e­cules. Bil­lions of years had to pass, and gen­er­a­tions of stars had to come and go, before life became a possibility.

Chem­istry and biol­o­gy require a flow of ener­gy, from the fab­u­lous­ly hot inte­ri­ors of stars to the unimag­in­able cold of inter­galac­tic space. Only in tiny enclaves pre­cise­ly placed in this flow is biol­o­gy pos­si­ble. The Earth is one such enclave.

Physi­cists have all the uni­verse to play with. Chemists are basi­cal­ly con­fined to the galac­tic neigh­bor­hoods of stars. The realm of biol­o­gists is those sliv­ers of space — just so far from a star and not too far — where mol­e­cules such as water can exist as liq­uids, some­where between steam and ice.

If, as most cos­mol­o­gists now believe, the uni­verse will expand for­ev­er, then the sci­ences will leave the stage in the reverse order in which they made their entrance. As the uni­verse is stretched increas­ing­ly thin, the stars will even­tu­al­ly cease to shine and the flow of ener­gy will stop. Life will be extin­guished first, then chem­i­cal activity.

Physics is indif­fer­ent to the tem­per­a­ture of the uni­verse. The infi­nite tem­per­a­ture of the first instant, or the absolute zero of the end — it is all part of the territory.

High-school sci­ence might be a lot more fun if it were taught in the con­text of the uni­verse’s sto­ry. The cre­ation myths of our ances­tors begin with biol­o­gy: A human­like divin­i­ty says, “Let there be light.” And they end with biol­o­gy, too; the lights go out with human his­to­ry. The mod­ern uni­verse sto­ry starts and ends with physics, with biol­o­gy con­fined some­where to the mid­dle, and with even chem­istry — bor­ing old chem­istry — get­ting its star turn on the stage.

Share this Musing: